| Name | Year |
|---|
| Sabol, Blake | 2017 |
| Sabourin, Jerrud | 2010 |
| Sagenelli, Anthony | 1994 |
| Sala, Dave | 1984 |
| Salnik, Mitch | 1969 |
| Salsgiver, Lance | 2004, 2005 |
| Salvo, Sebastian | 2014 |
| Samplinski, Rich | 1988 |
| Samra, Don | 1983 |
| Sanborn, Kyle | 1988 |
| Sanchez, Ezequiel | 2016 |
| Sanders, David | 2001, 2002 |
| Sanford, Scott | 1985 |
| Santo, Rob | 1984 |
| Santos, Jesse | 2001 |
| Saris, Jimmy | 2008 |
| Sarno, Gary | 1973 |
| Saumsiegle, Bill | 1969 |
| Savastano, Scott | 2007 |
| Savino, Dominic | 2018 |
| Sawyer, Marc | 2005, 2006 |
| Saylor, Cameron | 2013 |
| Scarpa, Glenn | 1982 |
| Scepaniak, Robert | 1967 |
| Schank,Jeff | 2015, 2016 |
| Schmitt, Eric | 1998 |
| Schmitz, Daniel | 1976 |
| Schufeit, Doug | 1971 |
| Schutz, Kipp | 2008 |
| Schwanke, Will | 2013 |
| Schwarber, Kyle | 2012, 2013 |
| Schwartz, Steven | 2006 |
| Scott, Brian | 1989 |
| Scott, Gary | 1987 |
| Scott, Josh | 1999 |
| Seander, Mike | 2008 |
| Searles, Ian | 2014 |
| Searcey, Jay | 1983 |
| Sebra, Bob | 1981 |
| Sebring, Jeff | 1995 |
| Seed, John | 1975 |
| Seibert, Mac | 2015 |
| Selma, Quentin | 2019 |
| Selmer, Ryan | 2016 |
| Semanchick, Gary | 1969 |
| Sems, Benjamin | 2019 |
| Sepede, Cameron | 2016 |
| Sessoms, Rob | 1985 |
| Sewell, Lance | 2007 |
| Shadid, Andrew | 2017 |
| Shaddy, Chris | 1981 |
| Shapiro, Brian | 2002 |
| Shaver, Colton | 2016 |
| Sheets, Ben | 1998 |
| Sheets, Gavin | 2016 |
| Shenton, Austin | 2018 |
| Shepard, Fred | 2012 |
| Sheridan, John | 2012 |
| Shepard, Fred | 2012, 2013 |
| Shepard, Kevin | 2003 |
| Sheppard, Darryn | 2015 |
| Shields, Nick | 2001 |
| Shimp, Steve | 1992 |
| Shortell, Rory | 2002 |
| Shrewsberry, John | 1979, 1980 |
| Shumock, Craig | 1980 |
| Sickles, Joe | 1982 |
| Simpson, Tucker | 2013 |
| Sims, Drew | 2019 |
| Sipp, Tony | 2003 |
| Sismondo, Bobby | 1997 |
| Sismondo, Ron | 1981 |
| Sittig, Billy | 2004, 2005 |
| Slaats, Josh | 2008, 2009 |
| Sladovnik, Scott | 1995 |
| Small, Ethan | 2016 |
| Smallwood, Matthew | 2015 |
| Smartt, Chase | 2016 |
| Smith, Cody | 2017 |
| Smith, Danny | 1980 |
| Smith, Jake | 2016 |
| Smith, Mark | 1990 |
| Smith, Jonathan | 2010 |
| Smith, Stan | 1980 |
| Sneed, John | 1996 |
| Snyder, Earl | 1996 |
| Sorgius, Steven | 1972 |
| Soto, Ty | 2002 |
| Southard, Scott | 1992 |
| Sowers, Jeremy | 2002, 2003 |
| Sowers, Josh | 2003, 2004 |
| Sowers, Logan | 2015 |
| Spears, Shane | 1993 |
| Spiezio, Scott | 1992 |
| Springer, George | 2009, 2010 |
| Spitzbarth, Shea | 2015 |
| Sprengel, Nick | 2016 |
| Sprowl, Robert | 1976 |
| Stabile, Ed | 1979 |
| Stack-Babich, Tom | 2008 |
| Stadler, Fitzpatrick | 2017 |
| Stanczak, Jack | 1991 |
| Stanicek, Steve | 1981 |
| Stapler, Cole | 2016 |
| Stapleton, Scott | 1993 |
| Stapleton, Steve | 1993 |
| Stark, Denny | 1995 |
| Stavinoha, Nick | 2003 |
| Steffan, Bill | 1978 |
| Steffen, Karl | 1977 |
| Sternagle, John | 2015 |
| Stetzar, Cole | 2019 |
| Stevens, Chad | 2019 |
| Stevenson, Jason | 2000 |
| Stevenson, Shawn | 1998, 1999 |
| Stewart, Brock | 2013 |
| Stewart, Clayton | 2003 |
| Stewart, Gregory | 1997 |
| Stiegler, Alex | 2018 |
| Stine, Justin | 1997 |
| Stone, Dave | 1970 |
| Stone, David | 2000 |
| Stone, Eric | 1987 |
| Stone, Jim | 1984 |
| Stoops, Dylan | 2012 |
| Stott, Bryson | 2018 |
| Stoudemire, Ryan | 2018 |
| Straub, Tim | 1987 |
| Sturgeon, Cole | 2012, 2013 |
| Stupienski, Gavin | 2015 |
| Suarez, Ignacio | 2002 |
| Suggs, Colby | 2012 |
| Suggs, Terry | 1986 |
| Sullivan, Pat | 1984 |
| Sullivan, Ryan | 2012 |
| Suter, Brent | 2011 |
| Suttle, Bradley | 2006 |
| Swaggerty, Bill | 1978 |
| Swagerty, Jordan | 2009 |
| Sweet, Jonathan | 1993 |
| Swisher, Nick | 2000 |
| Sylvester, Anthony | 1995 |
