| Name | Year |
|---|
| Packard, Bryant | 2018 |
| Palka, Daniel | 2011, 2012 |
| Palmeiro, Preston | 2014 |
| Palmer, Trent | 2019 |
| Parascand, Steve | 1984, 1985 |
| Parcus, Kyle | 2002 |
| Parhamovich, Andre | 1971 |
| Parisi, Michael | 2002 |
| Parker, Michael | 2006 |
| Parker, Nathan | 2007 |
| Parker, Tyler | 2000, 2001 |
| Parks, Pavin | 2018 |
| Parr, Benton | 2015 |
| Parreira, Brian | 2016 |
| Parrett, Jeff | 1982 |
| Parrott, Rhett | 1999, 2000 |
| Parsons, Jeff | 1994 |
| Patsos, Chris | 1980, 1981 |
| Pavlovic, Andy | 1980 |
| Payne, Danny | 2005 |
| Peck, Jeffrey | 1995 |
| Peeples, Jeff | 1970, 1971 |
| Pena, Carlos | 1997 |
| Pena, Omar | 2001 |
| Pena, Pedro | 2001 |
| Pendleton, Lance | 2003 |
| Penix, Troy | 1991 |
| Pepitone, Nick | 2009 |
| Perakslis, Stephen | 2011 |
| Perlman, Max | 2008, 2009, 2010 |
| Perry, Philip | 2001 |
| Persing, Tim | 1989 |
| Peterson, Darin | 1993, 1994 |
| Peterson, William | 2014 |
| Petiton, Matt | 2007 |
| Pettinicchi, Russ | 1969 |
| Pfaadt, Brandon | 2019 |
| Pfaff, Eric | 1983 |
| Pfisterer, Eric | 2009, 2010 |
| Phegley, Josh | 2007 |
| Phillion, Jay | 1982 |
| Phillips, Parker | 2018 |
| Phoenix, Wynter | 1994 |
| Pickler, Jeff | 1997 |
| Pierce, Bob | 1966 |
| Pineda, Ryan | 2008, 2009 |
| Pinkman, Pat | 1999, 2000 |
| Pirtle, Brett | 2013 |
| Pittaro, Chris | 1980 |
| Pittman, Mark | 1983 |
| Pleicones, John | 1983 |
| Plesac, Zach | 2015 |
| Plummer, Dale | 1987 |
| Plympton, Jeff | 1985 |
| Podratz, Trevor | 2013 |
| Poff, John | 1972, 1973 |
| Pompey, Tristan | 2017 |
| Pontiff, Wally | 2002 |
| Pop, Zachary | 2016 |
| Porter, Greg | 2000 |
| Poteet, DJÂ Â | 2019 |
| Powell,Tom | 1971, 1972 |
| Prater, Levi | 2019 |
| Prete, Jim | 1965, 1966, 1967, 1970 |
| Price, Jared | 2015 |
| Prior, Dan | 1977 |
| Prisco, Paul | 1986 |
| Prochaska, Mike | 2000 |
| Proctor, Will | 2018 |
| Pryor, Jonathan | 2016 |
| Pyror, Randy | 1988 |
| Purdy, Bill | 2007 |
| Pustay, Michael | 1976 |
| Putkonen, Luke | 2006 |
