| Name | Year |
|---|
| Cabe, Chris | 1997, 1998, 1999 |
| Cacciatore, Frank | 1972 |
| Cacciatore, Mark | 1972 |
| Caffrey, Gary | 1968, 1969, 1970 |
| Caffrey, Martin | 1972 |
| Calhoun, Willie | 2014 |
| Calica, Andrew | 2015 |
| Camacho, Vladimir | 2012 |
| Campbell, Darin | 1986 |
| Campbell, Raynor | 2008 |
| Cannon, Kevan | 1994 |
| Cantrelle, Lee | 1992 |
| Carey, Paul | 1987 |
| Carmona, Willie | 2011 |
| Carnes, Matt | 1996 |
| Carney, Robert | 1997 |
| Carrera, Jose | 2015 |
| Carroll, Cody | 2018 |
| Carter, Tommy | 1990 |
| Caruso, Claud | 1997 |
| Casanova, Carlos | 1993 |
| Case, Brad | 2017 |
| Casey, Mike | 1982 |
| Cassavechia, Nick | 2006 |
| Castlebery, Kevin | 1988 |
| Cathcart, Gary | 1983 |
| Cavalli, Cade | 2018 |
| Cavasinni, Mike | 2007 |
| Cello, Mike | 1966 |
| Cellucci, Brendan | 2018, 2019 |
| Chappell, Dave | 1976 |
| Charest, Joseph | 2011 |
| Chavers, Danny | 1998 |
| Chenault, Ethan | 2021 |
| Chester, Carl | 2016 |
| Chiaramonte, Joe | 1971 |
| Chinea, Chris | 2013, 2014 |
| Chism, Jim | 1981 |
| Chrismon, Thad | 1994 |
| Chrysler, Clint | 1996 |
| Chzanowski, Thomas | 1968 |
| Ciaramella, Frank | 1968 |
| Cicatiello, Gary | 1977 |
| Cichon, David | 1968 |
| Cieri, Nick | 2015 |
| Cisarik, Brian | 1987 |
| Cizynski, Joe | 1977, 1978 |
| Clapinski,Chris | 1990, 1991 |
| Clark, Bailey | 2015 |
| Clark, Brian | 1993 |
| Clark, Stan | 1980 |
| Cleary, Quinn | 2019 |
| Clementi, Dominic | 2018 |
| Clontz, Brad | 1991 |
| Cobb, Coy | 2019 |
| Coburn, John | 1965 |
| Coburn, Lawrence | 1965 |
| Cody, Kyle | 2013, 2014 |
| Cole, Mark | 1986, 1987 |
| Collins, Isaac | 2018 |
| Collins, Joel | 2005, 2006 |
| Collins, Sherman | 1986 |
| Collins, Tom | 1968, 1969 |
| Colorusso, Sam | 1988 |
| Concepcion, Alberto | 2000 |
| Conine, Brett | 2016, 2017 |
| Conley, Fred | 1993 |
| Conrad, Jim | 1973 |
| Contreras, Joaquin | 1984 |
| Copeland, Josh | 2005 |
| Coplon, Mitch | 1980 |
| Cormier, Lance | 2000 |
| Corr, Frank | 1998 |
| Corrada, Dick | 1970 |
| Cosgrove, Tom | 2016 |
| Coursen-Carr, Will | 2013 |
| Coutts, Jackson | 2018 |
| Cox, Darron | 1988 |
| Cox, Robert | 1976 |
| Crawford, Marty | 1994 |
| Creswell, Brandon | 1999 |
| Crockett, Ben | 2000, 2001 |
| Culbertson, Peyton | 2017 |
| Culpo, Gus | 2018 |
| Cunha, Steve | 1990 |
| Cuniff, Gerald | 1965 |
| Cunningham, Bill | 1983, 1984 |
| Cunningham, Tim | 2002 |
| Cupps, Anthony | 2004 |
| Curry, Mike | 1977 |
| Curry, Mike | 1997 |
| Cutura, Andro | 2013 |
| Cuas, Jose | 2014 |
