
BREWSTER, Mass. — Whitecaps manager Jamie Shevchik could only tip his cap to the opposition.
Brewster managed just five hits in a 2-1 loss to the Chatham on Tuesday night at Stony Brook Field, but Shevchik was hardly frustrated with his team’s lack of offensive production. The Whitecaps, he admitted, ran into a buzzsaw on the mound.
“Those were probably three of the better arms that we’ve seen consecutively the entire summer,” Shevchik said of the Anglers' pitching. “It had nothing to do with us having a lack of hitting, we just ran into three really good pitchers.”
Brewster put runners on base and in scoring position throughout the game, but the three Chatham pitchers — Karson Ligon (Mississippi State), Brian Zeldin (Georgia) and Titan Hayes (Austin Peay) — found ways to escape jams and induce big outs in the low-scoring contest. They were each aided by stellar defense, which came through in several big spots.
It started in the first inning, when Whitecaps leadoff man Nick Dumesnil was hit by a pitch, only to be thrown out attempting to steal second.
Brewster put its first runner in scoring position with one out in the second inning after Brody Donay (Florida) and J.D. Rogers (Vanderbilt) singled, but Cooper Vest (BYU) grounded into a 1-6-3 double play to end the threat.
After going down 1-2-3 in the third and fourth, small ball helped the Whitecaps take the lead in the fifth. Drew Faurot (Florida State) and Rogers both singled to lead off the inning, and Vest bunted them over. Ross struck out the following at-bat, but Faurot scored on an 0-2 wild pitch for the evening’s first run.
“We can do it,” Shevchik said of the unselfish approach. “It just comes down to if our guys are willing to do it. [Vest] is a guy who’s willing to bunt guys over if he has to. So the more we have of that, the better we’re going to be.”
On the other side of the ball, Brewster starter Luke Guth was rolling in his second start of the season. The Vanderbilt product cruised through his first three innings, allowing just three base runners with three strikeouts. He faced some trouble in the fourth but escaped — in large part to some impressive defense behind him.
Chatham catcher Ike Irish (Auburn) ripped a leadoff single and right fielder John Bay (Austin Peay) muscled a base hit into shallow center the following at-bat, sending Irish toward third. Center fielder DeAmez Ross rifled a perfectly placed toss to third baseman Andrew Fischer, who tagged out Irish for the first out of the inning. Guth retired the next two batters to keep the game scoreless.
When his day was done, Guth had pitched five shutout innings, allowing four hits and recording five strikeouts.
“He got himself into a few jams, but he had the stuff and the arsenal to get out of it,” Shevchik said of Guth. “He made some really good pitches at some big moments. So for him to go five innings of shutout baseball, that’s big.”
Ashton Crowther (Miami) replaced Guth in the sixth. He worked around a one-out double to end that inning scoreless but surrendered the tying run in the seventh after center fielder Austin Overn (USC) cranked a two-out RBI triple to right-center.
The Whitecaps nearly retook the lead in the bottom of the seventh, but overzealous baserunning resulted in another missed opportunity. Rogers drew a two-out walk, stole second and rounded third for home after Vest singled. He was thrown out by left fielder Ashton Larson (LSU), whose toss beat Rogers by a few steps and quelled the threat.
A half-inning later, Larson delivered for Chatham again — this time at the plate. After Campbell Smithwick (Mississippi State) walked and advanced to third on a stolen base and error, Larson laced a two-out RBI double off reliever Will Ray (Wake Forest) to give the Anglers a decisive 2-1 advantage.

The Whitecaps squandered another potential opportunity to draw level in the eighth. Ross, the leadoff man, reached on an error, and newcomer Kaeden Kent (Texas A&M) hit a one-out bloop single to left — his first hit with Brewster. Following the theme from throughout the night, though, Ross was thrown out at third after the pitcher, Hayes, covered the base.
The Whitecaps were caught out on the basepaths on five occasions — two on attempted steals, one on a pickoff and two on the outfield assists in the seventh and eighth. Still, Shevchik was pleased that his players stuck to the team’s aggressive identity — even if the results backfired at times on Tuesday night.
“I’m not pissed off that [Ross] got thrown out at third, because I would rather our guys be overly aggressive than to be underaggressive,” Shevchik said. “I’m okay with that.”
The hard-throwing Hayes stayed in for the ninth, reaching high-90s velocity in a 1-2-3 frame to close out the ninth.
“Today is a loss, but I’m not pissed off about it,” Shevchik said. “There are a lot of things that kind of hurt us, but the biggest thing is that we faced really good pitchers.”
Title photo credit: Avery Raimondo.





